FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
New Aii Report Examines Infrastructure Opportunities and Risks of Proposed Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern Merger
Analysis explores potential improvements in freight efficiency, safety, and resilience while emphasizing measurable commitments and effective oversight.
WASHINGTON, D.C., November 17, 2026. The Alliance for Innovation and Infrastructure (Aii) today released A New Supply Chain: Opportunities and Limitations for Infrastructure Resilience in the Proposed Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern Railroad Merger. The report examines how combining the two railroads could change the operation, management, and resilience of a freight network spanning roughly 50,000 miles across 43 states.
The proposed transaction would create the first single-operator transcontinental railroad in United States history. Aii’s report takes no position on whether the merger should be approved, focusing on the opportunities and responsibilities associated with operating existing infrastructure under unified leadership.
The analysis identifies potential benefits from reducing handoffs between railroads, strengthening connections between ports and inland markets, and simplifying coordination when supply chains are disrupted. A combined network could also support broader deployment of automated track inspection, fiber optic sensing, and common maintenance practices across thousands of miles.
“These potential benefits are not guaranteed, and consolidation cannot replace strong operational management,” the report states.
Greater integration also brings vulnerabilities. The report examines how centralized operations could amplify the consequences of cybersecurity incidents, localized failures, and poor management decisions. Previous railroad mergers illustrate how difficulties combining separate systems can disrupt service even when consolidation promises greater efficiency.
The report calls for Union Pacific and Norfolk Southern to identify which benefits depend on consolidation, explain how those improvements would be achieved, and establish measurable expectations for implementation. These could include reductions in interchange delays, improvements in service reliability, expanded infrastructure monitoring, and plans for managing operational and cybersecurity risks.
Alongside the report, Aii published an open letter addressed to the Surface Transportation Board (STB), which is reviewing the proposed merger under Finance Docket No. 36873. The letter emphasizes the importance of evaluating anticipated benefits against specific, credible, and measurable commitments, consistent with the Board’s public-interest review framework. Both publications are intended to inform policymakers, industry stakeholders, and the public without advocating for a particular regulatory outcome.
Authored by Owen Rogers and Benjamin Dierker, the report provides a framework for assessing how the proposed merger could affect the infrastructure supporting American freight transportation.
Read the full report: A New Supply Chain: Opportunities and Limitations for Infrastructure Resilience in the Proposed Union Pacific-Norfolk Southern Railroad Merger
Read the accompanying open letter: Aii Open Letter to the Surface Transportation Board
About Aii
The Alliance for Innovation and Infrastructure (Aii) is an independent nonprofit advancing infrastructure safety, efficiency, and resilience through research and education. Its work examines transportation, energy, technology, and public policy to inform practical solutions to infrastructure challenges.
Media Contact:
Aii Media Coordinator
info@aii.org
www.Aii.org