The Longest Running Statistic Gets an Update

 

Beneath Our Feet – Revisited

In August 2020, I wrote a policy blog called The Longest Running Statistic. It explored a rather peculiar question: How many miles of infrastructure are buried beneath the United States, and why have we been using the same estimate for decades?

At the time, the prevailing figure was more than 20 million miles. It was a familiar statistic in utility safety materials, government publications, and awareness campaigns encouraging people to contact 811 before digging.

But the more I looked, the more I found the same figure in older and older posts and publications. The history kept getting deeper, but the number was the same for decades.

In 1994, Bell Communications Research presented an estimate of 20 million miles at a National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) damage prevention workshop. The NTSB relied on that figure in a 1997 safety study, and the 1999 Common Ground Study repeated it while acknowledging that underground mileage had likely increased dramatically.

The Common Ground Alliance (CGA) subsequently helped popularize the figure through its national damage prevention messaging. By the time I began investigating its origins in 2020, the number had been circulating for more than a quarter century.

My observation then was simple: Even if there were actually, spitballing, say 50 million miles underground, the claim that there were more than 20 million would still be technically correct.

Fifty million was a hypothetical illustration just thrown out there, not a calculated estimate. But it raised an interesting question.

In light of major technological and population changes, could we update this statistic with reliable modern data?

Giving the Number a Second Look

The underground infrastructure network has changed substantially since 1994. Broadband and telecommunications networks have expanded, electric utilities have increasingly placed lines underground, and new homes, businesses, industrial facilities, and public infrastructure have required countless additional connections.

Yet the national estimate remained remarkably stubborn. Despite advances in digital mapping, no widely adopted, transparent national recalculation had replaced the old benchmark.

Some industry materials eventually and sporadically adopted figures closer to 30 or 35 million miles, often without citing a source or methodology. A handful of earlier niche subsurface utility engineering (SUE) publications had even suggested numbers around 50 million, but without a transparent national methodology explaining how they arrived there.

Rather than simply choose a larger number, Aii decided to revisit the underlying question. To do so, we had to start from scratch. So we settled on multiple approaches, with multiple models within each approach. That enabled us to generate a range of ranges, with varying levels of confidence, and the goal was to establish transparency and repeatability. That included external expert and peer review by PhD-level advisors with backgrounds in economics, law, engineering, and infrastructure. Their feedback helped us refine the models, better account for uncertainty, and improve how the findings were presented. We also consulted industry researchers, compared our findings against independently developed estimates, and presented the work to a graduate quantitative methods class for additional questions and scrutiny.

On March 19, 2026, the Alliance for Innovation and Infrastructure published Measuring the Underground: Advancing a New Estimate for the Total Linear Mileage of Buried Infrastructure in the United States.

The research employed three complementary approaches: bottom-up aggregation of documented infrastructure, extrapolation from state-level utility data, and historical growth modeling. Across the models, central estimates generally ranged from approximately 41 million to 55 million miles, with several clustering near 50 million.

The resulting recommendation was a new national benchmark of approximately 50 million miles of buried infrastructure in 2025.

Importantly, this was not a physical inventory or an assertion that every buried facility had been counted. It was a transparent modeling exercise, complete with assumptions, uncertainty ranges, methodological limitations, and opportunities for future refinement.

It helps that the number is memorable and round, but the top line estimate is not the most important part. The research behind it and publishing our process for others to pick up and run with is the real value.

A Busy Year Underground

We published report during Aii’s sixth annual Modern Roots March, an educational campaign designed to help Americans understand the infrastructure hidden beneath their feet. The updated estimate became part of that campaign’s public-facing materials and offered a useful new perspective heading into April’s National Safe Digging Month.

With approximately 50 million miles of buried facilities, the importance of contacting 811 before excavation becomes even more apparent. There is much more underground than most people imagine, and in some places, even infrastructure owners lack complete records of what is there.

The estimate began traveling beyond Aii as well. Virginia811 helped share the new research, and the Fiber Optic Sensing Association featured the findings in its March newsletter. By July, Brilliance Security Magazine was citing and linking directly to Aii’s estimate in a discussion of protecting buried cables and other physical infrastructure.

In August, the estimate reached another milestone with the publication of Holding Back Disaster: Protecting Lives and Infrastructure Through Excavation Damage Prevention, a Routledge book I coauthored with Scott Landes.

The book brought together extensive historical research, expert interviews, industry perspectives, and peer review to examine the people, policies, institutions, and technologies responsible for protecting underground infrastructure. Chapter 4, Utilities and Facilities, specifically revisited the old 20-million-mile estimate, explained why an accurate national count remains so difficult, and drew directly on Aii’s new research to present approximately 50 million miles as the updated national benchmark.

An August 8 report in The Epoch Times also discussed the 50-million-mile estimate while examining the scale of America’s excavation safety challenges.

For National 811 Day on August 11, industry technology firm 4M Analytics also published A Utility Strike Is Not an Accident, explicitly referencing Aii’s estimate and linking to the underlying research.

Industry uptake was already beginning, but then the figure received critical national attention.

On August 18, Washington, D.C.-based ABC7/WJLA aired a story about the importance of contacting 811, featuring PHMSA Administrator Paul Roberti and CGA President and CEO Sarah Magruder Lyle. The accompanying broadcast described the country’s underground utility network as approximately 50 million miles long.

The U.S. Department of Transportation subsequently shared the segment on LinkedIn, connecting the figure with the work of PHMSA and CGA. PHMSA and other notable safety agencies and leaders also amplified the video.

By September, the updated number was appearing more broadly in safety messaging and news coverage.

Following a severed fiber-optic line that disrupted air traffic across the Northeast on September 21, CGA issued a statement the following day emphasizing the importance of buried infrastructure protection. In her statement, Sarah Magruder Lyle referred to more than 50 million miles of buried utility lines as the backbone of modern America. The statement was subsequently quoted by industry publications, including Fierce Network.

The progression illustrates why an updated national benchmark was so useful. Lyle had referenced “more than 20 million miles” in September 2025, while CGA’s public materials used “more than 20 million” in March 2026 and “more than 30 million” in April. By September, its messaging reflected the newer 50-million-mile benchmark.

And on November 4, Lyle used the figure again in a Las Vegas Sun guest column explaining why temporary utility markings on streets and sidewalks are essential to public safety.

These were welcome developments. CGA has played a central role in building the nation’s damage prevention practices and public awareness, and its use of the updated figure helps communicate the scale of the infrastructure that its members and partners work to protect.

It was also gratifying to see the estimate move from a research question to a routine part of the national infrastructure conversation in a matter of months.

What to Make of It

There is something especially satisfying about revisiting an old research question and finally having a better answer.

In 2020, I wondered aloud whether the country’s underground infrastructure might be far more extensive than the prevailing 20-million-mile estimate suggested. Six years later, Aii published a detailed analysis supporting approximately 50 million miles as a more defensible modern benchmark.

That estimate has since appeared in educational campaigns, a peer-reviewed industry book, technology-sector publications, federal communications, statements by national industry leaders, and news coverage.

Not every passing reference to a widely used statistic needs a lengthy explanation of its methodological history. That is particularly true of public safety messages, where clarity and brevity matter. Indeed, research is most useful when its findings extend beyond the original publication and become part of broader public understanding. But the reason those messages can be short and confident is that the research has already been done and documented. Anyone who wants to know where the number came from should be able to find out.

The 2026 Measuring the Underground study provides that record for the approximately 50-million-mile estimate, with its methodology, assumptions, and limitations laid out for others to examine and improve. In 2020, tracing the old 20-million-mile figure back to its origins took some detective work. If someone in 2050 wonders where the 50-million-mile number came from, I hope the study – or even this blog – saves them some of that trouble.

A better estimate will eventually be needed. Underground infrastructure continues to expand, and improved mapping and data should help us count it more accurately. Perhaps the next estimate will be 55 million, 60 million, or something altogether different. We should welcome that work. After all, the objective was never to replace one outdated statistic with another that would last for 30 years. It was to improve our understanding of the infrastructure beneath us and give future researchers something to build upon.

One final observation: After all this research, we can now say with considerably more confidence that America has more than 20 million miles of buried infrastructure.

Technically, we were right all along. We just know a little more about how much more.

Written by Benjamin Dierker, Executive Director

The Alliance for Innovation and Infrastructure (Aii) is an independent, national research and educational organization. An innovative think tank, Aii explores the intersection of economics, law, and public policy in the areas of climate, damage prevention, energy, infrastructure, innovation, technology, and transportation.